The Ick vs Lurke: Hourly Checks or Unlimited Accounts? (2026)
Updated November 19, 2026. Competitor facts are taken from Lurke's website.
Short answer: The Ick and Lurke work the same basic way: both save a public profile's lists and compare them later, and neither asks for an Instagram login. Pick The Ick if you want a published schedule, with every tracked profile checked each hour and each new follow, new follower and unfollow logged with the time it was detected. Pick Lurke if you want a native iPhone app, unlimited tracked accounts, or a monthly or lifetime plan (25 USD once on the US App Store), and you are fine with scans that have no published interval.
The Ick and Lurke are separate companies with no connection to each other. The Ick is made by Vaste Company and runs at theick.io and on Google Play. Lurke is published by NaviStack LLC at lurke.app, on the App Store and on Google Play. Lurke is also not Lurk: Lurk runs at getlurk.app and comes from a different maker, as Lurke's own site points out. Lurk has its own page: The Ick vs Lurk.
How we compared: on 19 November 2026 we read Lurke's site summary, its pricing page, its terms, its guide to the following list order, its comparison index and its App Store and Google Play listings, and we quote what those pages say. Where its pages do not state something, the table says so.
| Feature | The Ick | Lurke |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | Web app at theick.io (works in Safari on iPhone, can be added to the home screen) and an Android app on Google Play. Not currently on the Apple App Store. | An iPhone app and an Android app, according to its website. The website itself offers a search preview and free tools. |
| Instagram login required | No. You only type a public Instagram username. | No. Its website says it never asks for your Instagram password or login codes. |
| What it tracks | New follows and unfollows in both directions (who the profile started or stopped following, and who started or stopped following them), follower and following count changes, a history timeline, and a gender breakdown of recent follows. | Newly detected followers, unfollowers, accounts a profile started following, accounts that do not follow back, and follower and following totals over time, according to its website. Likes and stories are separate free web tools and are not tracked. |
| Shows recency/order of follows | New follows are detected by comparing hourly snapshots and shown in the order they were detected, each with a timestamp. Follows made before tracking started are listed without a date. | Snapshot comparison. Its website says the first completed full scan sets a baseline and changes appear from later scans. It lists the exact time of a follow and a chronological follow history among the things it cannot show. |
| Update frequency | Every hour, for each tracked profile. | Not published. Its store listings say scans are not real time and can take time to complete. Pro includes more on-demand refreshes. |
| Profiles per plan | Up to 5 public profiles per subscription. | Unlimited tracked accounts with Pro, according to its store listings. |
| Alerts | Push notifications in the Android app when a change is detected. | Push alerts after a completed scan, with Pro only, according to its pricing page. |
| Private accounts | No. Public profiles only. | No. Its website says it works with public Instagram accounts only. For your own account, the app can import Instagram's data download. |
| Pricing (as published) | 8.99 USD per week or 29.99 USD per year in the US, lower prices in many countries. Pay by card, Apple Pay or Google Pay. | Its pricing page and US App Store listing show 7.99 USD per week, 14.99 USD per month, 39.99 USD per year and 25 USD for lifetime access; a 19.99 USD special offer can appear. Its Google Play listing shows in-app purchases from 7.99 to 39.99 USD per item. |
| Free trial or preview | Yes. Type a username on theick.io and see a 5-step analysis preview before subscribing. | A free account can preview a public profile and its follow counts, according to its pricing page. Full scans and alerts need Pro. No free trial is promised; its terms say an introductory offer applies only when one is shown. |
| Refund policy | Cancel anytime from Settings. Access continues until the end of the current billing period. | App purchases are refunded through Apple or Google, and website purchases through its support email. Its terms say canceling a subscription does not automatically refund previous charges. |
| Ratings/reviews | Rated 4.5 on Google Play with over 203,000 ratings. | Rated 3.0 on the US App Store from 2 ratings. Its Google Play listing showed more than 1,000 downloads and no rating on 19 November 2026. |
The real difference: a fixed hourly check or scans with no published interval
The Ick and Lurke use the same method, and Lurke is open about it. Its site says the first completed full scan sets a baseline, that changes appear from later scans, and that it cannot show the exact time of a follow or a chronological follow history. Its guide, checked by its authors in October 2026, says Instagram has no date-followed sort for any following list.
The Ick works the same way: it saves the full following and followers lists of a public profile, checks again and compares. Each account that appears is logged as a new follow or a new follower, each account that disappears is logged as an unfollow, and follows made before tracking started are listed without a date.
The difference is the clock. The Ick checks every tracked profile every hour and stamps each change with the time it was detected, so you know the hour in which it showed up. Lurke does not publish how often it scans. Its store listings say scans are not real time and can take time to complete, and that Pro adds more on-demand refreshes. The longer the gap between two scans, the wider the window in which a change could have happened.
Since September 2026 Instagram only shows a following list in date order to the owner of the account, which is why trackers like these two compare snapshots. The background is in Instagram following list not in chronological order and how Instagram follow trackers work.
Pricing in detail
The Ick costs 8.99 USD per week or 29.99 USD per year in the US, and less in many countries. The pricing page shows the price in your local currency.
Lurke's pricing page and US App Store listing show four plans: 7.99 USD per week, 14.99 USD per month, 39.99 USD per year and 25 USD once for lifetime access. Its listing also shows a 19.99 USD special offer that can appear. So Lurke is 1 USD cheaper by the week, The Ick is 10 USD cheaper by the year, and Lurke's lifetime plan costs less than one year of either.
The plans cover different things. Lurke Pro tracks unlimited accounts with no published scan interval. The Ick covers up to 5 profiles, each checked every hour. Lurke's free account previews a profile and its counts; full scans and alerts need Pro, and its terms do not promise a free trial.
Who each one is best for
The Ick is the better fit if timing matters to you. Every tracked profile is checked every hour, every new follow, new follower and unfollow gets a detection time, and the web app at theick.io works on iPhone, Android and desktop. Android users also get push notifications from an app rated 4.5 on Google Play from more than 203,000 ratings.
Lurke is the better fit if you want a native app on your iPhone, need to watch more than 5 accounts, or prefer to pay once: 25 USD for lifetime access is hard to beat if you plan to use a tracker for more than a few weeks. It also lists accounts that do not follow back, and it can import your own Instagram data download.
For the wider field, see the best app to see who someone follows on Instagram.
What Lurke does that The Ick does not, and the reverse
In Lurke's favour: native apps on both iPhone and Android, unlimited tracked accounts with Pro, a monthly plan and a 25 USD lifetime plan, a list of accounts that do not follow back, an import of your own Instagram data download, and free web tools for likes and stories.
In The Ick's favour: a published hourly check, a detection time on every change, a web app that also works on desktop, a lower yearly price, and a larger public track record: 4.5 on Google Play from more than 203,000 ratings and over 1 million downloads, against 3.0 from 2 ratings on the US App Store and no rating yet on Google Play for Lurke.
One note on naming. Lurke (lurke.app, by NaviStack LLC) and Lurk (getlurk.app) are different products from different makers, and neither is connected to The Ick. The official app page lists the official places to get The Ick.
Verdict
The Ick and Lurke are built on the same honest method, so the choice is practical. Lurke gives you native apps on both stores, unlimited accounts and a 25 USD lifetime plan, with scans on a schedule it does not publish. The Ick gives you 5 profiles checked every hour, with every new follow, new follower and unfollow logged with the time it was detected.
If knowing when a change showed up matters to you, type the username into theick.io and look at the free preview first.
Try The Ick on any public profile
No Instagram login. See recent follows in seconds.