The Ick vs Red Flag Follows: Dated Hourly Log or Undated Recent-Follows List? (2026)
Updated November 19, 2026. Competitor facts are taken from Red Flag Follows's website.
Short answer: Pick The Ick if you want a dated record on Instagram: it checks up to 5 public profiles every hour and logs every new follow, new follower and unfollow with the time it was detected. Pick Red Flag Follows if you also want TikTok, a slightly lower weekly price (7.99 USD against 8.99 USD), email alerts, or one-off checks on many accounts, and you are fine with a list that has no dates, no unfollows and alerts on one account at a time.
The Ick and Red Flag Follows are separate products with no connection to each other. The Ick is made by Vaste Company and runs at theick.io and on Google Play. Red Flag Follows runs at redflagfollows.app and describes itself as an independent service; its pages name no company or person.
How we compared: on 19 November 2026 we read Red Flag Follows' homepage, its how-it-works page, its guide to the best apps for seeing who someone recently followed, its terms and its privacy policy, and we quote what those pages say. Where its pages do not state something, the table says so.
| Feature | The Ick | Red Flag Follows |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | Web app at theick.io (works in Safari on iPhone, can be added to the home screen) and an Android app on Google Play. Not currently on the Apple App Store. | Web, in your phone's browser, according to its guide. Its terms and privacy policy refer to an app billed by Apple or Google, but its pages link to no store listing and we found none under this name. It covers Instagram and TikTok. |
| Instagram login required | No. You only type a public Instagram username. | No. Its website says it never asks for your password. |
| What it tracks | New follows and unfollows in both directions (who the profile started or stopped following, and who started or stopped following them), follower and following count changes, a history timeline, and a gender breakdown of recent follows. | Recent follows only: up to the last 200 on Instagram and 100 on TikTok, grouped into women, men and others by an AI model, according to its how-it-works page. It does not cover unfollows, likes, comments or stories. |
| Shows recency/order of follows | New follows are detected by comparing hourly snapshots and shown in the order they were detected, each with a timestamp. Follows made before tracking started are listed without a date. | Says it shows the existing following list newest first, as an order with no exact dates. Its how-it-works page says Instagram's September 2026 change did not affect it, because it uses a source that still returns follows newest first, last re-tested on 14 October 2026. |
| Update frequency | Every hour, for each tracked profile. | Every 2 hours for alerts, according to its website. A manual refresh is allowed once an hour per account, and results are cached for 24 hours. |
| Profiles per plan | Up to 5 public profiles per subscription. | Alerts on 1 account, which can be switched once a week, plus unlimited one-off checks, according to its website. |
| Alerts | Push notifications in the Android app when a change is detected. | Email when the account follows someone new. Its how-it-works page says alerts are for new follows only. |
| Private accounts | No. Public profiles only. | No. Its website says it only works with public accounts. |
| Pricing (as published) | 8.99 USD per week or 29.99 USD per year in the US, lower prices in many countries. Pay by card, Apple Pay or Google Pay. | 7.99 USD per week on the web, renewing automatically. No other plan is published. App pricing is not published. |
| Free trial or preview | Yes. Type a username on theick.io and see a 5-step analysis preview before subscribing. | Its how-it-works page says the first checks are free and show counts only. The number of free checks is not stated. |
| Refund policy | Cancel anytime from Settings. Access continues until the end of the current billing period. | Its website says to email within 7 days of a charge to ask for a refund. |
| Ratings/reviews | Rated 4.5 on Google Play with over 203,000 ratings. | No store listing found. Its site shows anonymous five-star testimonials only. |
The real difference: a dated log of changes or an undated order
Both products answer the question of who someone recently followed, and they answer it in different ways.
The Ick records changes. It saves the full following and followers lists of a public profile, checks again every hour and compares. Each account that appears is logged as a new follow or a new follower with the time it was detected, and each account that disappears is logged as an unfollow. Follows made before tracking started are listed without a date, because Instagram does not publish when they happened.
Red Flag Follows shows a list. Its how-it-works page says it displays up to the last 200 accounts a profile followed on Instagram, in the order they were followed and without exact dates, grouped into women, men and others. It does not track unfollows, and its alerts are for new follows only.
Since September 2026 Instagram only shows a following list in date order to the owner of the account. Everyone else gets a ranked list. Red Flag Follows is one of the few tools that addresses this directly: it says the change did not affect it, because it uses a source that still returns follows newest first, last re-tested on 14 October 2026. Its guide describes the comparison of who shows newest first on a first check as its own test. That order cannot be checked against anything Instagram publishes, so the practical test is to try both on a profile whose recent follows you already know. The background is in Instagram following list not in chronological order and how Instagram follow trackers work.
Pricing in detail
The Ick costs 8.99 USD per week or 29.99 USD per year in the US, and less in many countries. Red Flag Follows costs 7.99 USD per week on the web and publishes no other plan. By the week Red Flag Follows is 1 USD cheaper. For anything longer than a few weeks The Ick's yearly plan costs far less, because Red Flag Follows has no yearly option.
One correction. Red Flag Follows' guide, which its authors checked on 14 October 2026, lists The Ick at 34.99 USD per year. The published US price is 29.99 USD per year, as shown on the pricing page.
What the price covers is also different. Red Flag Follows gives alerts on 1 account, switchable once a week, plus unlimited one-off checks, on Instagram and TikTok. The Ick tracks up to 5 Instagram profiles, each checked every hour. Red Flag Follows' site says you can email within 7 days of a charge to ask for a refund.
Who each one is best for
The Ick is the better fit if you want to know what changed and when. Unfollows are logged as well as follows, on both the following side and the follower side, every event has a detection time, and 5 profiles are checked every hour. Android users get push notifications from an app rated 4.5 on Google Play from more than 203,000 ratings. iPhone and desktop users use the web app at theick.io.
Red Flag Follows is the better fit if you want TikTok as well as Instagram, alerts by email, or quick one-off looks at many accounts for a weekly price that is 1 USD lower. It suits a short check more than a long-running record, because nothing in its list is dated and unfollows are not shown.
For the wider field, see the best app to see who someone follows on Instagram.
What Red Flag Follows does that The Ick does not, and the reverse
In Red Flag Follows' favour: TikTok support, email alerts that reach any phone or computer, unlimited one-off checks, a lower weekly price, first checks that are free, and a stated 7-day window to ask for a refund.
In The Ick's favour: unfollow tracking in both directions, new followers as well as new follows, a detection time on every change, checks every hour instead of every 2 hours, 5 tracked profiles instead of alerts on 1, a yearly plan, and a public track record: 4.5 on Google Play from more than 203,000 ratings and over 1 million downloads, against no store listing found for Red Flag Follows.
One note on what Red Flag Follows says about The Ick. Its guide describes The Ick as hourly, with push alerts, up to 5 accounts and an Android app, which is right. It also cites US App Store ratings for The Ick. The Ick is not on the Apple App Store; the official app page lists the official places to get it, and its public rating is the Google Play one.
Verdict
Red Flag Follows is a simple tool: an undated list of recent follows on Instagram and TikTok, email alerts on one account and a single 7.99 USD weekly plan. The Ick is a tracker with a record: up to 5 Instagram profiles checked every hour, with every new follow, new follower and unfollow logged with the time it was detected, for 8.99 USD per week or 29.99 USD per year in the US.
If you want to be able to say what changed and when, type the username into theick.io and look at the free preview first.
Try The Ick on any public profile
No Instagram login. See recent follows in seconds.