The Ick vs Stalkie: Hourly Checks or Email Alerts and Profile Changes? (2026)
Updated November 19, 2026. Competitor facts are taken from Stalkie's website.
Short answer: The Ick and Stalkie use the same method and are honest about the same limit: follows made before tracking started cannot be dated. Pick The Ick if you want hourly checks, up to 5 profiles and the follower side as well, meaning who started and who stopped following the profile. Pick Stalkie if you want email alerts, a weekly summary, alerts on profile changes such as a new bio or photo, or a two-profile comparison, and 3 profiles checked several times a day is enough.
The Ick and Stalkie are separate products with no connection to each other. The Ick is made by Vaste Company and runs at theick.io and on Google Play. Stalkie runs at stalkie.app; its site names only Stalkie as the responsible party, and its Android app is published on Google Play by Vinícius Moreira. Stalkie has a page about The Ick alternatives, and what it says there about The Ick is accurate.
How we compared: on 19 November 2026 we read Stalkie's homepage, its follow tracker page, its page on the following list order, its best-apps guide, its page of The Ick alternatives, its terms, its privacy policy and its Google Play listing, and we quote what those pages say. Where its pages do not state something, the table says so.
| Feature | The Ick | Stalkie |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | Web app at theick.io (works in Safari on iPhone, can be added to the home screen) and an Android app on Google Play. Not currently on the Apple App Store. | Web in any browser, and an Android app on Google Play. No iPhone app. |
| Instagram login required | No. You only type a public Instagram username. | No. Its website says you sign in to Stalkie with your email or Google, not with Instagram. |
| What it tracks | New follows and unfollows in both directions (who the profile started or stopped following, and who started or stopped following them), follower and following count changes, a history timeline, and a gender breakdown of recent follows. | Follows and unfollows of the tracked profile with date and time, profile changes (name, bio, photo, account going private), a searchable following list, a two-profile comparison and a weekly summary. New followers are not offered, according to its own comparison page. |
| Shows recency/order of follows | New follows are detected by comparing hourly snapshots and shown in the order they were detected, each with a timestamp. Follows made before tracking started are listed without a date. | Snapshot comparison. Its website says each change is dated by when it was spotted and that the history starts when tracking starts. Its privacy policy says activity history is kept for up to 30 days. |
| Update frequency | Every hour, for each tracked profile. | Several times a day, according to its website, with no number given. Its Google Play listing describes real-time alerts. |
| Profiles per plan | Up to 5 public profiles per subscription. | Up to 3, according to its own best-apps guide. |
| Alerts | Push notifications in the Android app when a change is detected. | A phone notification or an email, plus a weekly summary, according to its website. |
| Private accounts | No. Public profiles only. | No. Its website says only public accounts. |
| Pricing (as published) | 8.99 USD per week or 29.99 USD per year in the US, lower prices in many countries. Pay by card, Apple Pay or Google Pay. | Web price not published. Its terms say some features require a paid subscription. Its Google Play listing shows in-app purchases from 4.99 to 12.99 USD per item, without labelling the periods. |
| Free trial or preview | Yes. Type a username on theick.io and see a 5-step analysis preview before subscribing. | Not published. Its website says searching a username needs no account. |
| Refund policy | Cancel anytime from Settings. Access continues until the end of the current billing period. | No policy of its own. Its terms say refunds follow the rules of the store or payment processor. |
| Ratings/reviews | Rated 4.5 on Google Play with over 203,000 ratings. | Its Google Play listing showed more than 5,000 downloads and no star rating on 19 November 2026. No App Store listing. |
The real difference: how often, how many and which side of the list
The Ick and Stalkie work the same way. Stalkie's site says it compares the following list over time, dates each change by when it was spotted, and that the history starts when tracking starts. The Ick saves the full following and followers lists of a public profile, checks again and compares, and lists follows made before tracking started without a date.
Three things separate them. The first is cadence: The Ick checks every tracked profile every hour, and Stalkie's site says several times a day without giving a number. The second is capacity: up to 5 profiles on The Ick, up to 3 on Stalkie. The third is scope: The Ick logs new followers and lost followers as well as follows and unfollows, while Stalkie's own comparison page says it does not offer new followers.
Stalkie goes wider in another direction. It watches the profile itself, with alerts when the name, bio or photo changes or the account goes private, and it has a two-profile comparison and a weekly summary. Its privacy policy says activity history is kept for up to 30 days.
Since September 2026 Instagram only shows a following list in date order to the owner of the account, which is why both products compare snapshots. The background is in Instagram following list not in chronological order and how Instagram follow trackers work.
Pricing in detail
The Ick costs 8.99 USD per week or 29.99 USD per year in the US, and less in many countries. The pricing page shows the price in your local currency before you pay.
Stalkie does not publish a web price. It has no pricing page, and its terms say only that some features require a paid subscription. Its Google Play listing shows in-app purchases from 4.99 to 12.99 USD per item without saying which period each one covers, so Stalkie may well cost less, but the pages we read do not let us say by how much. Check the price shown at checkout.
Its terms have no refund policy of their own and say refunds follow the rules of the store or payment processor.
Who each one is best for
The Ick is the better fit if you want the tightest timing and the fullest record of the lists: every tracked profile is checked every hour, up to 5 profiles per plan, with follows, unfollows, new followers and lost followers each logged with the time detected. Android users get push notifications from an app rated 4.5 on Google Play from more than 203,000 ratings, and the web app at theick.io works on iPhone, Android and desktop.
Stalkie is the better fit if you want alerts by email, which reach any phone or computer, or if you care about changes to the profile itself: a new bio, a new photo, an account going private. It also has a weekly summary and a two-profile comparison.
For the wider field, see the best app to see who someone follows on Instagram.
What Stalkie does that The Ick does not, and the reverse
In Stalkie's favour: email alerts, a weekly summary, alerts on profile changes (name, bio, photo, account going private), a searchable following list and a two-profile comparison.
In The Ick's favour: checks every hour, up to 5 profiles instead of 3, new followers and lost followers as well as follows and unfollows, published prices, and a public track record: 4.5 on Google Play from more than 203,000 ratings and over 1 million downloads, against a Stalkie listing with more than 5,000 downloads and no rating shown when we checked.
One note on what Stalkie says about The Ick. Its alternatives page describes The Ick fairly, and states that The Ick checks more often and follows more profiles. It presents Stalkie as the closest match on iPhone because it runs in the browser. The Ick's web app also runs in the iPhone browser, so on iPhone the two are used the same way. The official app page lists the official places to get The Ick.
Verdict
The Ick and Stalkie are close in method and both are straightforward about what cannot be known. Stalkie adds email alerts, a weekly summary and profile-change alerts for up to 3 profiles, at a web price it does not publish. The Ick checks up to 5 profiles every hour and logs follows, unfollows, new followers and lost followers with the time each was detected, at a published price.
If hourly checks or the follower side matter to you, type the username into theick.io and look at the free preview first.
Try The Ick on any public profile
No Instagram login. See recent follows in seconds.